As Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana prepares to table the delayed 2025 National Budget to Parliament, the stakes for South Africa’s economic future and the credibility of the Government of National Unity (GNU) coalition have never been higher. The budget, initially postponed in February due to disagreements over a proposed VAT increase, is now under intense scrutiny as investors, policymakers, and citizens alike await clarity on the country’s fiscal direction.
The Risks of Another Delay
The postponement of the February budget set a troubling precedent, exposing cracks in the GNU coalition and raising concerns about transparency and trust among its partners. If another delay occurs, it could severely damage South Africa’s credit rating and reputational risk, increasing the cost of borrowing in international markets. Currently, South Africa’s credit ratings from Moody’s (Ba2), S&P, and Fitch (BB-) are at the lower end of investment grade, signaling substantial risk to investors.
Key Budget Challenges
Godongwana faces a daunting task in balancing competing priorities:
- Public Debt: South Africa’s debt service costs are projected to reach R1.341 billion over the current term, straining an already tight fiscal space.
- Social Safety Net: The government’s social safety net, including grants and welfare programs, costs R1.221 billion, raising questions about sustainability.
- Public Sector Wage Bill: At 13.6% of GDP, South Africa’s public sector wage bill is one of the highest in the world, further limiting fiscal flexibility.
- Tax Revenue: Subdued GDP growth and low tax-to-GDP ratios have constrained revenue collection, complicating efforts to fund critical expenditures.
The VAT Debate
One of the most contentious issues in the budget is the proposed VAT increase. Initially, Godongwana suggested a two-percentage-point hike to raise R60 billion, but this faced fierce opposition from coalition partners like the Democratic Alliance (DA). A compromise, such as a smaller VAT increase or differential application targeting high-end sectors, is now under consideration. However, any VAT adjustment risks exacerbating inequality and punishing low-income households.
Investor Confidence and Global Relations
The Treasury’s decision to follow up the budget speech with a series of investor update meetings in Cape Town and Johannesburg underscores concerns about South Africa’s credit and reputational risk. The Trump administration’s hostile stance toward South Africa, fueled by figures like Elon Musk and Afrikaner lobby groups, has added to the pressure. Pretoria is now seeking to strengthen partnerships with the European Union (EU), a key ally in funding initiatives like the Just Energy Transition Programme.
The GNU Coalition’s Credibility
The GNU, formed after the ANC lost its outright majority in the 2024 elections, is still in its infancy. While coalition governments are inherently complex, the delay in passing the budget has exposed fault lines and raised questions about the coalition’s ability to govern effectively. The DA’s inability to block controversial legislation like the Expropriation Act and the National Health Insurance (NHI) Bill has further strained relations.
What’s at Stake?
For millions of South Africans, the budget is more than just numbers—it’s about their daily lived experiences. High unemployment, rising living costs, and rampant crime have left many disillusioned. Failure to address these issues could deepen social divides, creating a three-tier society: the wealthy urban elite, the “protected” social net generation, and the rest of the population struggling to make ends meet.
The Path Forward
Godongwana’s budget must strike a delicate balance between fiscal discipline and social equity. Key priorities include:
- Economic Growth: Stimulating GDP growth to create jobs and boost tax revenue.
- Debt Management: Reining in public debt to reduce servicing costs and free up resources for development.
- Social Spending: Ensuring the sustainability of social safety nets while addressing inefficiencies.
- Investor Confidence: Reassuring investors through transparent and credible fiscal policies.
As South Africa navigates this critical juncture, the budget’s success will hinge on the GNU’s ability to overcome internal divisions and deliver a plan that restores confidence, fosters growth, and addresses the needs of all citizens. Another delay or misstep could have far-reaching consequences, not just for the economy but for the country’s social fabric and global standing. The ANC’s founding fathers and liberation heroes would surely expect nothing less than a bold and inclusive vision for South Africa’s future.
{source : IOL}
Follow Joburg ETC on Facebook, Twitter , TikTok and Instagram
For more News in Johannesburg, visit joburgetc.com